Scent is often promoted as a way to sharpen memory, but a new study published in Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience suggests the picture is more complicated. Researchers from UCLA, working with Leal and colleagues at Rice University, found that young and older adults who completed memory tasks in a room scented with lavender essential oil did not perform significantly better than people in an unscented room.
The study recruited healthy young and older volunteers with no signs of Alzheimer's disease. Each participant first took a standard olfaction test to establish baseline smell function. Half entered a room already scented by a lavender diffuser, and half entered an unscented room. They then viewed two sets of images of everyday household objects, such as a blow dryer or tomato, that differed in how many features they shared. Participants who saw the first set with the scent saw the second set without it, and vice versa.
After a delay, participants were shown images that were identical to, slightly different from, or entirely different from the ones they had seen. Many objects had been subtly altered, so a red blow dryer might appear blue, which tested both general recognition and memory for detail. The main result was that odor made no difference for either age group on the overall measures. The researchers said this was surprising given earlier work suggesting smell could enhance memory.
The one clear pattern appeared in older adults, depending on timing. Those who smelled lavender during the first learning phase recalled the objects more accurately than those who encountered it during the second phase. Younger adults showed no such difference. Older adults who found the scent pleasant, and those with less olfactory dysfunction to begin with, also showed better detail memory.
Leal argued that the study points toward novelty as a key factor. "If we want to support memory in older adults, we need to think beyond simply whether a stimulus helps or hurts memory and consider when and how it is experienced," Leal said. The authors conclude that scent may be more useful when deployed strategically rather than as a general memory booster, and they highlight the possible importance of novel sensory experiences during learning as people age.
The research also connects to a wider interest in smell as a possible signal for Alzheimer's, since age-related olfactory decline has been linked to the disease and has prompted interest in smell changes as an early detection tool. The study was funded by the National Science Foundation, the BrightFocus Foundation, the Brain and Behavior Research Foundation, and the Alzheimer's Association.